Arriv guide · New York
Fantasy Football Draft Party Venues in New York
New York, NY · 2-day plan · 8 places
A 2-day plan for New York with times, tips, and extras beyond the spine.
Stays on this map
Hotels and rentals near these pins.
Browse stays in New YorkArriv may earn a commission if you book through this link.
2-day New York itinerary
Tap a stop to see it on the map. Adjust freely once it’s your trip.
Day 1Day 1 — Draft Day Setup
Jake's Dilemma
4.0
430 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
Tip — Rent the Living Room uptown—beer pong between picks keeps everyone loose for 4+ hours.
Mustang Harry's
4.4
352 7th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA
Tip — Three floors near MSG fit 450 people; move here after if your league wants to spread out post-draft or into evening.
Day 2Day 2 — Watch & Argue
Smithfield Hall NYC
4.4
138 W 25th St, New York, NY 10001, USA
Tip — 32 screens at Smithfield Hall, right above the 1 train at 23rd—your whole league can get there without logistics drama.
Porchlight
4.4
271 11th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA
Tip — Game Room has darts and cards in a 19th-century warehouse; pivot here for dinner and sideline games once the main slate winds down.
Where to go in New York
8 places across 2 lists — options beyond the day plan.
On the plan
Rent the Living Room to avoid the main-floor crush, and you get a dedicated server plus beer pong and other games to fill downtime between picks.
The Game Room has darts, cards, board games, and an AV setup inside a refurbished 19th-century warehouse with Southern design, so you're not just staring at screens.
Three floors near MSG with 85+ screens and 450-person capacity, so your whole league fits without anyone missing plays.
A British pub with 32 screens and room for 300, sitting right above the 1 train at 23rd Street—easy for everyone to reach.
More to explore
Stout NYC
Stout has 40+ screens across multiple locations (Penn Station, FiDi, Grand Central, Bryant Park) and can fit 300 people, plus they offer a 3-hour open bar package in a private room or cordoned table.
The Dead Rabbit
Book the Occasional Room here for a draft party with the cocktail bar's high-end spirit list and Irish-dive hospitality in one room.
Professor Thom's
East Village spot with a devoted craft-beer menu and a heavy Boston sports crowd, so expect strong opinions during the draft.
Legends
Near Herald Square with 39 screens and a rooftop bar, giving your group options if you want to split time between game-watching and air.